The shock of Hamas’s victory in the recent Palestinian elections has led many western commentators and politicians to re-consider their assumption that western style democracy should be brought to the Muslim world. Some have argued that Islamists such as Hamas should never have been allowed to participate in the elections and, moreover, that free elections are not appropriate in conservative Muslim countries where secular parties are weak. In contrast, others have argued that no such conclusion should be derived from the Palestinian election results, asserting instead that the results represented a protest vote against the corruption of Fatah and that with time Hamas will become more pragmatic when faced with the challenge of governing. On two issues vis-à-vis Hamas, however, there seems to be almost universal agreement amongst western commentators: firstly, that Hamas should repudiate the use of violence against Israel and secondly that Hamas should recognize the right of the Jewish state to exist.